Challenged Incumbents to Remain on Ballot
Objections to the petitions for candidacy filed by several village board members were denied at an electoral board meeting on Sunday.
Editor's note: This article was altered after publication to correct the spelling of Mary Beth Windberg's name.
Village board incumbents George Metanias, Joe Werner, John Mazzorana and Joe Siwinski will remain on the ballot in April’s election.
A meeting of the Mokena Officers Electoral Board was held Sunday to address recent objections to their petitions for candidacy.
The objections were filed by the Mokena Friends and Neighbors Candidates — a group of nonpartisan, non-incumbent candidates also running for various positions within the village. The Friends and Neighbors include Frank Fleischer, Jenifer Sciaky, Mary Beth Windberg, Vincent L. Di Fiore and Tony Bruozas.
The electoral board is comprised of Dan McGrath, Lawrence Gryczweski and Patrick Carey, who were appointed to their positions by the Chief Judge of Will County.
Metanias’ petition was challenged on the grounds that he withdrew the petition after filing it and then filed it again later on the same day.
The petitions filed by Werner, Siwinski and Mazzorana were challenged because the Friends and Neighbors claimed that none of the petitions contained the minimum number of signatures from registered voters who live in Mokena. For the 2012 election, village candidates are required to collect at least 223 valid signatures.
“I never thought I did anything wrong,” said Metanias, in an interview with Patch. “I didn’t withdraw my petitions. I didn’t walk out of the room”
During Sunday’s meeting, Karl Ottosen, the legal advisor for the Friends and Neighbors, called on Village Administrative Assistant and Deputy Clerk Judi Frieling and Village Board Candidate Tony Bruozas, each of whom was present when Metanias filed his petition.
Both Frieling and Bruozas said that Metanias took his petition back from the village clerk after filing it when he was told that he would have to be in a lottery due to a simultaneous filing. He then returned the petition within the following five to ten minutes, they said.
However, Doug Heathcock, the legal representative for the four incumbents, said the Friends and Neighbors failed to meet the findings of the burden of proof, meaning that there was not enough evidence presented to prove that Metanias’ actions were invalid.
“You haven’t heard that there was any alteration,” Heathcock said to the board. “You haven’t heard that a page was added. You haven’t heard that a page was withdrawn.”
The board denied the objection, with a 2-1 vote.
“We strongly disagree with the ruling that it was a proper thing for Mr. Metanias to take back his petition,” said Ottosen, after the meeting. “We’re disappointed in the decision here.”
The validity of numerous signatures appearing on petitions filed by Werner, Siwinski and Mazzorana was also questioned during the meeting. The signatures were examined for several reasons, including improperly listed addresses, inconsistent handwriting, the inclusion of signatures from residents who were not registered to vote and signer fraud.
“We believe that there were enough questionable signatures to at least bring the objection and let the board determine which ones were valid and which ones were not,” said Ottosen.
Although 28 signatures were removed from Werner’s petition during the electoral board meeting, the petition still included 238 valid signatures after the removal. The objection filed by the Friends and Neighbors was unanimously denied.
“You have to trust the process,” said Werner. “If there isn’t a process that you can live with, then you’re never going to be effective.”
Following the board’s denial of Werner’s objection, Ottosen voluntarily withdrew the objections to the petitions filed by Siwinski and Mazzorana. Ottosen told Patch that the objections were withdrawn because they were very similar to the objection filed against Werner.
The electoral board will officially deliver its findings to the candidates at a meeting at 6 p.m. on Jan 15.
Get news alerts and Facebook updates from these Lincoln-Way Patch sites:
Ron Kenning
9:17 pm on Sunday, January 13, 2013
Time for new blood at the helm!
someone nice
10:10 pm on Sunday, January 13, 2013
I personally like George and I think if you think you can do a better job in Mokena and the empty store fronts then maybe you should run .Why aren't you mentioning any of the good things he has done.Hmmm maybe your just a martyr.Let's not take into account that the economy has gone to crap and maybe that's why we have empty store fronts .Seems to me you might want to find a hobby other than causing drama and discrediting people
MMF
10:30 pm on Sunday, January 13, 2013
Hi "Mr. Johnny on the spot," I appreciate what you have to say, but if you want to challenge us all to as you say: "contact me I got plenty to tell lots of hush hush stuff I welcome you to knock on my door and place your signs in my yard !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!", then you need to step up and tell us who you are and how to contact you and quit hiding behind your veil of ambiguity. Talk is cheap.
Anna Schier
11:47 pm on Sunday, January 13, 2013
Johnny on the spot,
Your comment was deleted because it contained personal attacks, which is a violation of Patch's terms of use.
Thank you for reading,
Anna
Amanda Bowl
1:40 am on Monday, January 14, 2013
Thankfully the incumbants won at the hearing!
Eric Blair
6:28 am on Monday, January 14, 2013
Mindless post. Wasted use of this platform.
Eric Blair
6:47 am on Monday, January 14, 2013
Who is this Doug Heathcock character? Seems he’s always lurking around behind the shadows only reveling himself at strategic times. Where did he come from and what is his interest in this group of neo cons? He seems to be their “handler”. Who is controlling him and why? Someone or something big appears very intent on keeping the bunch together. Why? Anybody know? Something doesn't seem right here.
Amanda Bowl
7:28 am on Monday, January 14, 2013
Doug Heathcock is an excellent attorney who lives in Mokena and his law firm is in Joliet. Doug is a very active citizen in Mokena and an active parent in the school district. He doesn't lurk in the shadows, but is all out in the open.He is nobodies handler. No one controls anyone else. The incumbents were objected to and they hired legal counsel, and paid him. No favors. Something appears very intent on getting the Fleischer bunch in. Why? Anybody know? Something doesn't seem right here.
Eric Blair
7:42 am on Monday, January 14, 2013
I would suggest to you that it would be wise to look up the meaning of the term “useless idiot”.
Amanda Bowl
11:17 am on Monday, January 14, 2013
Mindless post. Wasted use of this platform.
Norm
11:48 am on Monday, January 14, 2013
Amanda, thanks for explaining who Doug Heathcock is. He did an excellent job. And Eric, thank you for explaining, in your own way, the definition of a useless idiot.
Eric Blair
4:59 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
It’s over your head Norm, way above your intellect. Besides that this community and politics all over certainly don’t need more lawyers in the equation. Lawyers have messed this country up enough already.
Eric Blair
5:09 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
You didn't look it up.
Norm
6:16 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
There are a lot of things that may go over my head, Eric, but bias wrapped in self righteous indignation is easy to spot. Your little diatribe on lawyers, specifically Doug Heathcock, was revealing in that Karl Ottosen was not once mentioned. It wasn't Mr Heathcock who brought these frivolous complaints to the electoral board.
RP22
6:33 am on Tuesday, January 15, 2013
Of the 56 signers of the Declaration of Independence, 25 were lawyers. Of the 55 framers of the Constitution, 32 were lawyers.
Eric Blair
8:44 am on Tuesday, January 15, 2013
Acknowledged. That was then, this is now. However modern lawyers/politicians have perverted our system of laws to levels unforeseen by our Founders. Back then a layman could read and understand written law. Nowadays with legalese the laws are purposefully written so laymen cannot understand them. Also back then the laws were clear as opposed to modern law which is mostly arbitrary. I stand by my prior post: less lawyers in the mix
Norm
12:00 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
The headline should have read:
Frank Fleischer's Follies Foiled - Future Finished.
RP22
6:41 am on Tuesday, January 15, 2013
Follies? Frank is a right and just man. Let's hear what he has to say.
Cliff
9:55 pm on Wednesday, January 16, 2013
Here's a headline:
Fleischer Flies Faster, Finishes First.
Mokena Voter
12:40 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
Mr. Heathcock certainly has a right to represent whomever he pleases for whatever fee he chooses. A bigger question is why Mr. McGrath, a paid village employee, did not recuse himself from serving on the electoral board. He should have followed the lead of the mayor and stepped down. Would have also been good reporting if Anna Schier would've noted that In the article.
Eric Blair
5:08 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
Interesting. Thanks for pointing that out.
Eric Blair
5:44 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
Why would anyone defend and vote for an incumbent politician who has already done two terms? Most of these trustees going on even more than that. This commenter is not defending the challengers, haven’t seen their platform as yet. That’s not the point. A major problem with this country is due to career politicians because the American people don’t rotate them nearly enough. Politicians by nature are mostly psychopaths who are control freaks and narcissist. They need to be replaced periodically. Once entrenched in power they lose touch and become corrupt. M. Madigan comes to mind. One way or another it’s past time to replace the current crew. Whoever comes out on top this commenter wants to see far more openness. With modern technology at our fingers there is no excuse to not to put all Village business on line. In Mokena “they” keep lots of semi-secrets. One is forced to file a FOIA request for what should be online. This isn't right and it’s only one point of dissatisfaction.
Norm
6:31 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
Eric Blair: "Politicians by nature are mostly psychopaths who are control freaks and narcissist."
You have a door knob collection in the attic, Aunt Clara?
Follow the Law
6:15 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
A Village employee with nothing to gain or lose (Deputy Clerk Mrs Frieling ) testified that Trustee Metainias withdrew his Petitions from her and then after 5 to 10 minutes resubmitted them . Mr Broziuos who is a candidate also stated this but let's assume he had something to gain and his testimoney could be suspect ! So we now have a Mokena Trustee who should above all show the integrity and character he claims to have and admit he made an inadvertent tactical mistake not knowing the ramifications and did indeed withdraw his Petitions which invalidated them and thus he would then only be able to run as a Write -In ! But NO we again have a POLITICIAN who cannot tell the Truth and due to the placement of a Electoral Board Chairman with an "absolute conflict" ( Mr McGrath is a paid Mokena contractor ) will remain on the Ballot . Trustee Metainias creates Ordinances and Laws that we the Mokena residents must follow but he the POLITICIAN of little Integrity does'nt have to . It is very unfortunate this occurred but the Law is the Law and Trustee Metainias by his actions and statements is now perjuring the Sworn Word of Mrs Frieling . I would hope the ruling is appealed and the Chief Judge of Will County is made aware of Mr McGraths conflict and disregard of the letter of the law and reverses this. I question Mr McGraths integrity and he should have recused himself when appointed ! I agree that Anna Schier should review this and if a conflict exists notify the Court !
Follow the Law
6:20 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
It seems ironic that Mr McGrath as the Mokena Hearing Officer is the one who Rules on the Ordinance and Law Violations that Trustee Metainias enacts and creates ! This isn't a CONFLICT ?
Amanda Bowl
7:06 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
Follow the Law: The petitions never left the sight of anyone in that room! Otteson had his time yesterday to prove his case and he couldn't. Fleischer and company should have prepared for the hearing better if they are so convinced they are right.
Follow the Law
8:27 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
The Law states the Petition cannot be withdrawn ! When Trustee Metanias took them back from Deputy Frieling he withdrew them , her Testimony stated exactly that ! Leaving the room has nothing to do with it , there is an opening in the window into the Clerks office and through this the Petitions were submitted to Deputy Clerk Frieling and then after being stamped and a receipt issued Trustee Metainias reached through and took them back into the LOBBY ! As they say on TV the Chain of Evidence was then broken . Mrs Frieling is the only person involved in this process with "nothing to gain or lose " and why would we not believe her Testimony ? She is a dedicated employee and a very nice person and resident of Mokena and she only told the Truth ! Shame you discredit her !
Follow the Law
8:32 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
Maybe the Chairman of the Board Mr. McGrath should have disclosed his interest/conflict in Mokena , and maybe since he is "appointed by the Mayor " and PAID to be the Mokena Hearing Officer his decision seemed obvious !
Follow the Law
8:58 pm on Monday, January 14, 2013
Eliminate all the players who have a vested interest in the Petition Challenge Metainias , Brozious and McGrath and just take the Sworn Testimony of Deputy Clerk Frieling ! What was her Sworn Testimony ?
Amanda Bowl
1:01 am on Tuesday, January 15, 2013
I have said nothing to discredit Mrs. Frieling. There was alot of nice people involved in this objection mess. Again, Sunday was the day to argue this out. For whatever reason it ended in Metanias favor. There was attorneys on both sides. Ask the attorneys why Metanias prevailed.
Fresh Ideas
4:25 pm on Tuesday, January 15, 2013
No you didn't say anything Negative about Mrs Frieling , she was put in a very difficult spot and give her a lot of credit showing honesty, integrity ,and character . Shame Metainias couldn't do the same ! He's now gone from a Mokena Trustee to a typical Politician he once stated to loath !
Norm
5:56 pm on Tuesday, January 15, 2013
Fresh Ideas/Follow the Law: Pick one screen name and stay with it.
Norm
8:49 pm on Tuesday, January 15, 2013
Robert Stillman - Where are you in our of need?
Norm
9:06 pm on Tuesday, January 15, 2013
Robert Stillman - Where are you in our hour of need?
I spell poorly too
11:26 pm on Tuesday, January 15, 2013
Cute Norm ! Cute , if your going to criticize at least have your game together ! Lol
Norm
9:03 am on Wednesday, January 16, 2013
My mistake wasn't spelling, it was timing; I missed an hour.
I spell poorly too
11:28 pm on Tuesday, January 15, 2013
PS: Norm , there are not only 3 or 4 people following this conversation !
Norm
9:15 am on Wednesday, January 16, 2013
I don't care about spelling. My response was to the two screen names (now three, including you) who use the exact same punctuation mistakes. Kinda like a fingerprint.
Mokena Parent
1:34 pm on Wednesday, January 16, 2013
Follow the Law: Are you a lawyer? Obviously not since its apparent you don't know the law. You only heard one side of the story, the objectors side. Obviously, they did not have a case against Trustee Metanias because they didn't even need his side to present their case. People lie all the time for whatever reason. Trustee Metanias is a dedicated trustee here to help the village and the people of Mokena. Unlike these guys running who only have one thing on their agendas, to discredit those in office now ( which they are doing unsuccessfully). I haven't heard anything from any of them about how they want to help the village, its just all about their attacks on the incumbants. The village is in good hands, in good shape, and better then ever! I hope the citizens look past all this mudslinging and see just how well the village is under these dedicated incumbants.
Eric Blair
7:06 pm on Wednesday, January 16, 2013
“The village is in good hands, in good shape, and better than ever!” That’s the same thing the residents of Dixon, Il said before it was discovered city comptroller Rita Crundwell diverted 53+ million$ into her personal accounts. That would be one good reason to replace the Mokena government and any politician for that matter, after two terms max. The Mokena administration for finances has been in position for a comparable amount of time. It does seem strange that most politicians including our own Mayor complain about their long hours and low pay and yet when time comes for the next election they fight ‘till their last breath to stay on. Maybe the pay isn't so low.
I spell poorly too
3:52 pm on Wednesday, January 16, 2013
Seems it doesn't matter that Trustee Metainias stated in today's Messenger " that he indeed did take back the Petitions through the window but didn't leave the Lobby and didn't think he did anything wrong " . This is exactly what Deputy Clerk Frieling said and Mr Brozious . It's important to know that the Election Board Chairman McGrath is a Village Hearing Officer appointed by the Mayor and he FORGOT to disclose this during the Hearing ! KANGAROO COURT
I spell poorly too
9:18 pm on Wednesday, January 16, 2013
Eric Blair , Mayor Werner works his full-time job in Blue Island , and also runs his plumbing business in Posen which by the way is on the list of plumbing companies provided by Mokena to contact to do an RPZ Test for Mokena residents sprinkler systems ( isnt that a conflict ) and he's our Mayor ! Wonder why we have a dismal economic development record ?
Sam Hill
9:31 pm on Wednesday, January 16, 2013
There are no provisions in the state statutes or Illinois election code for candidates to retrieve petitions and resubmit them after they have been filed. It matters not due to ignorance of the law, how nice the person may be or what they have or haven't done as an elected official.
Independent witness statements verify that candidate Metanias withdrew his petitions after he was informed that he was subject to a lottery for ballot position. Did he think he was making a strategic decision to avoid the ballot lottery? Only he can answer that question. The law is clear, once withdrawn, registered petitions cannot be resubmitted. It can be spelled or parsed it many different forms but those are the facts.
Each candidate has the responsibility to learn and understand election laws.
Doubt Chairman
4:11 pm on Thursday, January 17, 2013
It seems the Election Board Chairman ( who is also a paid Mokena Employee appointed by Mayor Werner ) forgot to disclose this conflict prior to or during the precedings and voted contrary to the Law . It's a shame because another Member of the Election Board disclosed he was a occasional acquaintance of one of the contestors , when he did this the Chairman should have followed suit. It's a real shame because these precedings are conducted while under Oath !
Bob Jones
9:39 pm on Sunday, January 20, 2013
I think Doug Heathcock should find out who pays the lowest real estate taxes on Cherry street.. If Doug won't do it, Frank Fleisher should because Frank is fearless, in fact he's fearless and factual. Let's call him fearless factual frank fleisher finding favoritism on Cherry Street. .