Board Approves Cutting 22 D161 Teachers; Raises Club, Band and Sports Fees
Because of decreasing enrollment, the Summit Hill school district board reduced its workforce, honorably dismissing teachers. The board also raised fees for clubs, band and sports at Wednesday's meeting to help with the district's bottom line.
- By Joe Vince
- Email the author
- March 29, 2012
Photos
Pdfs
CORRECTION: An early version of this story listed the wrong fee amount for clubs. It has been changed to the correct amount, $30.
For the first time in its history, the Summit Hill School District 161 board of education approved the honorable dismissal of 22 teachers at its Wednesday meeting as part of an overall staff reduction in the district.
The dismissals come as the district's student enrollment is projected to decrease and the board needs to cut more than $3 million from the D161 budget over the next three years. No tenured teachers were let go by the district, Supt. Barb Rains said, adding that a list of eliminated teachers would not be released in accordance with board policy.
Rains said she would provide Patch with a full list of teachers retained by the district some time Thursday.
Although the teacher cuts were approved unanimously, board member Sean William Doyle voted against the motions for non-renewal and reclassification of staff members. After the meeting, Doyle said because it was a personnel matter and the decision was discussed in closed session, he couldn't identify the staffers involed, but he said he objected to the reasoning behind the decision.
Rains also would not confirm the identity of the staffers.
Along with cutting teachers, the board also approved fee increases for clubs, sports and band. Club fees were raised to $30 per year, and sports fees were increased to $50 per year, and band was increased to $200 per year for the first child and $100 for the each additional child.
Check back later Thursday and Friday for continuing updates and read the transcript of the meeting's live blog for more details of what happened at Wednesday's board meeting.
Read More in Schools
D159 Schools Wear 'Jeans for Wishes'In This article
-
Mary Drew Elementary School
20130 S Rosewood Dr, Frankfort, IL41.524954-87.817101Mary Drew Elementary School
20130 S Rosewood Dr, Frankfort, IL815-469-3950/listings/mary-drew-elementary-school2022085/locations/5481619
See More on Patch
Most Popular articles
- Lincoln-Way High Schools Named Among Newsweek's Top in the Country
- 13-year-old Frankfort Girl Missing: Police Dog Lost Scent (UPDATE)
- Stolen Car Crashes into Semi on I-80
- Lincoln-Way East Griffins Celebrate Prom at Prestwick Country Club
- Defense Lawyers Want Judge Knocked Out of Mokena Coma Punch Case
Stella Nyder
8:54 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012
Please pray for the @ 9 teachers/staff who are being let go.
For God to help them as they will be receiving notification, make a way for them and comfort them and to encourage them.
May each one of them know how much we value them and to experience our support fully as they finsh the year strong! We are all saddened.
For the Lord help each member of the Board and administration and to help them lead with expertise and compassion. Especially for safety for all our students and for all of us to work together for their sake and for their quality education! they deserve our best! each one of them is so very precious. May our students continue to bring joy to each teacher as they are giving their best for our children to grow and learn!
Are you kidding me?
1:52 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012
35 positions, not 9?? And they just started.
caspert
12:04 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012
Stella that was beautiful. Hugo G not sure what to make of your comment. Wouldn't dedicated Kindergarten teachers be lost with half day Kindergarten also? I'm confused? I think your comment is sad.
caspert
7:25 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Not sure why these comments are under this article. It's the wrong one. This article makes me sick. 22 teachers there is no honor in dismissing the ones who worked hard and helped to get your district where it is. 22 people out of work in this economy especially in this line of work? Does anyone have any idea how hard it is to get a job as a teacher now? Absolutely disgusting. I want to know what makes these 8 people qualified to run this district? What qualifications do they have besides getting voted in by some? Also two getting voted in without searching for other outside applicants including one board member and the superintendent. I hope a house cleaning is in order on all fronts including superintendents next election. When is that contract up? Our community is being ruined and dragged through the mud with this behavior and personal agendas. I'm embarrassed, thouroughly disgusted, and angry. Also Board president stop talking in interviews or to anyone for that matter. Hard to believe there were no other options or things to look into the first year of a so called 3 year plan.
Joe Vince
11:32 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@caspert:
The original article with the live blog addressed what's in the above comments. It's since been updated. That's why those comments look out of place.
Also, some clarifications: Getting the most votes are all the qualifications you need to be a board member (outside, of course, the things that allow you to be an actual candidate, like living in the district and so on). The voting public elected them to run the district. Denise Wildeveld is the only board member who wasn't voted to the board, and she was appointed after the board did go through an application process and interviewed other candidates for the position.
Concerning Supt. Rains: Her contract is up June 30, 2013. The superintendent position also is not an elected position.
Joe Vince
Local Editor, Frankfort
Dana Johnston
8:32 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
For the 9 thousand dollars I pay in taxes what exactly am I getting?? My son will be in an overcrowded classroom, I will have to scrounge up more money if he wants to play any sports or God forbid he wants to play a musical instrument!!! Why not cut some of those administrative positions that are a waste of money!?!? It's appalling and my solution to it all......is move. I'd rather give my 9 grand to a district that is a little more worried about the EDUCATION than the prestige of their prescious colleagues!!
Joe Vince
11:39 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@Dana Johnston:
Administrative cuts are in the cost-cutting plan. The details haven't been discussed yet.
Joe Vince
Local Editor, Frankfort
Rose C
11:49 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@Dana - I can understand your frustration however, the district has guidelines for the number of students allowed in one class room depending on the grade level. Your child's class (more than likely) have 25 students or less. The community was begging the board a couple of months ago to increase fees, donate $150 per child, pay for bussing, etc. Thank goodness they only increased extra curricular fees. Other districts in the area charge upwards of $200 just to register a child for school. What administrative positions would you like to see cut? The Dir of Finance & Spec Ed Dir have resigned - I would guess that they could fill those positions for less $$. The Dir of Curriculum & HR Dir positions have been eliminated. So unless by adminstrative you mean secretaries (who make around $11/hr) who is there to cut loose?
Jaimi Nance Welsh
1:28 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@Rose...they eliminated the position of Curriculum Dir., cuz they unloaded it on an administrator that already has a full-time job in our district! But you see..this is how the 161 school board operates presently! If we were talking rational people here, than we would get rational solutions...Unfortunately..IRRATIONAL is the perfect word to describe our so-called board!!
Outraged
8:52 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
please remember your aggravation and frustration next April when several of these board members will be up for re-election!!!
Rose C
11:57 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
You know what Outraged, your right - people should be paying closer attention to their elected officials - but I would start higher up. Start with you who vote to represent you in Springfield. Someone needs to force the State to pay ALL of their outstanding bills to school districts - not just to the 'poor' districts. I hope we get people who are willing to run for the school board and put in the enormous amounts of 'free time' to do the best job they can. Although, the people who are coming to the meetings getting the crowd worked up or sending out misinformation - I don't I see them staying for an entire meeting - ask Mr. Marron what time he left IT last night. Whether you like these board members or you think they are all stupid - you are one vote outraged...and should you run for the board, guess what? You only get one vote there too.
Opinion 1
9:46 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
I agree with Outraged. If you do not vote for qualified candidates in the next election - the frustration will continue. Be proactive and voice your opinion with a vote - it is the only way. Regarding the sup - she was placed by the board - who again were voted into their position...high admin saleries definatey need to be reviewed and my last thought is YES these statements to the media by board members, board president and the sup needs to stop - get everything in order and then make statements on paper which would be submitted to the media - this way there is a record. Where is the professionalism in this entire process???
Rose C
12:01 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
I have to agree with your second argument Opinion 1. Media in any form can mislead or misinterpret what a board member says in an interview. (Sorry Joe) And then the reader can read into it whatever they want.
informed
2:37 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Hey can anyone give me an example of what a qualified board member may look like to you...!
vince
1:01 am on Friday, March 30, 2012
informed
the best example is that the current board members are not qualified.......at least three out of the four ladies that need to go.
Dana Johnston
12:57 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@Rose C,
I understand what you are saying and I am not expressing that the answer is to fire all administrators but we all know there are PLENTY of people in this school district who are OVERpaid and completely UNDERworked!! They may have a job title but basically just collect a check! It's a shame that the people who lose their jobs are the teachers which educate our children!! They also are paying these ridiculous taxes and for what....to have their hard work, their time and effort be thrown to the side because the others are tenures!! It's ridiculous that this district can't get it's act together. Everyone acts like this was some shock....that board knew that money wasn't coming through a looooong time ago.......but we needed that new high school and to raise my taxes to help pay for it! After living in Frankfort for 10 yrs. I will have paid more than $90,000........,for what? What in Frankfort is worth that amount of money?????
informed
3:01 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@Rose C, you have the most sensible comments....kudos for being rationale. This community would rather be lied to just like we have been for YEARS. This community is afraid of the truth. I pray that these seven volunteers keep up their strength and continue to address major issues....like a 3.8 million dollar deficit or after last night I believe we may have a 4.8 million dollar deficit if the state has it their way. Again, thank you Rose C.!
Kerri U
2:47 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@ Dana If you are paying $9,000 a year in taxes total, it doesn't all go to the school district, only approximately a 1/3 goes to Summit Hill School District. If that is 1/3 of your taxes, appreciate that you must have a lovely, large home to live in and pay for.
@ All Does anyone have VIABLE alternatives to what is being done?? I hear a lot of B&C but no ideas as to how to save funds in a different manner. Most of you are insulting tough decisions that needed to be made. We prevented the full day kindergarten from being disbanned. Did everyone think that we could ignore the deficit we are in and blame it on the administration?? The board, that was elected in by people that actually vote, doesn't even get paid to be crucified by the public. I am not saying I agree with every decision that they have made but I am saying I don't see anyone out there suggesting real solutions to the $3 million deficit. You cannot have your cake and eat it too, no matter what you have been told. I would recommend, instead of making up rumors and throwing out insults, you make an effort to get in touch with the current board and see if they will listen to your viable ideas.
taxpayer
3:53 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
I'm a little curious how many people commenting have even voted in the last several elections. In my personal opinion, if you didn't even go out to vote, you have no right to criticize. Its very possible that most of these board members will be voted out in the next election (since everyone is paying attention finally).
Whats going to happen when the person you vote in does something you don't like or doesn't agree with you.........do you deem them "unqualified"? We need to unite and not tear to shreds this wonderful school district. Yes, some board members have been very unprofessional but some of the actions by my fellow neighbors are embarrassing as well.
Also, I"m not understanding the rational in keeping staff if our enrollment is decreasing. No one wants to see someone loose their jobs but its a reality in this economy.
Also, every single time a person stands up at the podium to bring to light that they feel a rule what was broken, a code was violated, etc. do you realize they are racking up the attorney fee? We need to make sure these complaints are valid before a board meeting otherwise, we are just contributing to the high attorney fee.........another fee we can't afford
Are you kidding me?
5:44 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Taxpayer, Rich Marron's complaints all have been valid ones. Too bad the attorney has to be called everytime there is a board meeting because the president or super have no idea what they are doing! If they are dumb enough not to follow their own by- laws then oh well...Taxpayer, maybe you should address this directly with Rains and Kenny because they are the ones wasting your tax dollors and mine, not Rich Marron. The board has already torn this district to shreads, not the taypayers or parents. Unite what? we tried that and they would not listen and continue to follow their agendas. That was proven last night (with smiles on their faces.) Ask Kenny and the rest of them if they mind returning their expensive IPADS if your worried about things we cant' afford. Oh and I did vote in the last elections, not that its any of your business. SO, Rich Marron and anyone else who can, go ahead keep finding stupid mistakes our board president and $140,000.00 a YEAR superintendent keep making. Do you think they are budgeting legal fees for the 12/13 school year?! God only knows!
taxpayer
10:03 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
WOW Are you kidding me?, take a chill pill. I didn't name ANYONE nor did I say "hey, Are you kidding me? did you vote". Nor was I speaking directly to our about Rich Marrion so please stop insinuating. I've been to plenty of meetings, not just one or two. You know as well as I do that the majority of people complaining didn't vote. Sean Doyle made his way back in with 13% of votes which is crazy. The majority of this board has lost their marbles and have done alot of shady crap but the fact of the matter is, if they didn't hold the special meeting before the board meeting, they would have been criticized, they did hold a special meeting and they are still criticized. The community has lost all faith in this board which sometimes brings out the ugly. Just because the board doesn't want to unite with the community, we still need to unite as a community with each other. Maybe you have given up but I sure the heck havent.
sam
9:01 am on Friday, March 30, 2012
I agree taxpayer-after reading some of the comments on the live blog the other night I am embarrassed to see how many uninformed and ignorant people actually live in this district. Instead of tearing the board members apart for a very difficult job, maybe they should be trying to come up with solutions to help. Quit the mud slinging. Until you have walked in their shoes you have no right to criticize. Children learn what they live. Maybe that explains some of the discipline issues we have in the schools today.
Citizen
4:25 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@informed, Has the board already decided who will replace Beth? I didn't know they posted the job or interviewed candidates. What about the 2 openings at Hilda Walker?
Please (if you know) tell us how much we will have to pay into Jan and Jeff’s TRS for their early retirement. I'll bet it's more than we paid for Pain's retirement. Seems like we'll be spending a lot money (that we clearly don't have) to get rid of a few more administrators.
informed
5:35 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@citizen, I will repeat what I said "Oh no - what I HEARD is that Laura Geobal is going to take over for Beth Lind" my neighbor is a teacher in this district and told me she has applied for several different administrative positions in our district over the years...this teacher told me she is very very close to the board member Sean William Doyle, I believe he is the board member with the very long hair.
sam
9:11 am on Friday, March 30, 2012
It would not be a good idea to have a teacher that already works in the building "take over" for Beth Lind. If she applies yet again and is qualified to be placed at another district school that is one thing-but to put her in charge of the teachers that she is working with would be just be wrong. Opinions have already been formed. It doesn't matter that she is "very very close to the board member Sean William Doyle" Again another assumption.
Dede
1:15 pm on Friday, March 30, 2012
One close friend on the board cannot guarantee a job. Let's just hope that whoever gets hired has more people skills than Mrs. Lind. I was surprised to see the favorable comments about her in the blog. The SH staff is surely partying today.
informed
9:36 pm on Friday, March 30, 2012
I was just told that The Union Vice President Geobal has been feeding information to Mr. Richard Marron the trouble maker that likes to attack the board and hear himself talk at the school board meetings which is racking up legal fees and nothing comes of his ridulious accusations....neighbors of theirs told me how interesting it is that Geobal and Marron live across the street from one another.....it seems as though the triangle is Geobal, Doyle and the dupe doing their dirty work.
informed
5:37 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@citizen, who is Jan and Jeff and what are you talking about? Please be more clear ....
Citizen
5:58 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@informed, My mistake, I thought you might have had something to share with us.
Jeff and Jan are our 2 current Hilda Walker Administrators, Jan has already announced her intention to retire (early) and Jeff is not being offered a contract next year, he will most likely (if he can't find a job) be forced to retire early from the district.
Our district will have to make substantial payments to each of their TRS pensions.
jd
6:30 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@citizen how do you know all this? I have been listening to the board meetings on line and I never heard anyone talk about a substantial payment for early retirement. Please let me know which meeting you heard that at so I can listen to it also.
Citizen
7:06 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@JD - you won't find this on the podcasts. It's simply the way the industry works. If an administrator / teacher is over 50 years old, and have "x" amount of years, they can choose to retire early....(just like Keith Pain did) leaving the district to make substantial TRS deposits, Jan has already announced her intent to retire. I'm not sure how many years she has paid into in TRS, but am certain that she is retiring early. If Jeff is unable to find a job, he may be forced to retire (early). Not positive about this one, but the business manager- Dean, may also be eligible for early retirement. I'm not an expert, but I have several teachers in my immediate family and they say this is a common practice, especially when a administrator is not offered a contract or "forced out" by local school boards.
Rose C
8:12 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
"Forced Out" That sounds scandalous or at least something for reality tv. Wouldn't it be great if we had ONLY THE FACTS!?
jd
3:20 pm on Friday, March 30, 2012
@cititzen so what you said is that now you are not sure if anything you said before is true. You were so sure that Jan can retire early, how certain are you? Now you are not positive about Jeff. And Dean, you are not sure also. So how can anybody take anything you say as truth. As for Keith Pain, I'm sure you are positive about your statement about him also, right. Your statements are misleading and not backed up by any fact. And also your last statement about "forced out" I am sure your positive about that statement as well.
Citizen
11:42 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@JD - I'm sorry I responded to you, I didn't realize your goal was to try to discredit me. To everyone else, it is a well known fact Pain's early retirement cost 161 around 200K, Zevkovich's & Libowitz (should he choose to retire) will cost 161 considerably more than that.
informed
7:17 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@Citizen, boy you know it all...thank you for explaining that to me.
Citizen
7:42 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@informed - You are welcome! Anytime I can help!
Joe Vince- this would be a great topic for a Patch article. I'd love to know how much 161 has spent on early retirements for teachers / administrators in the last few years.
Rose C
7:27 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@Are you kidding - Rich Marron is just stirring the pot. I would rather the district err on the side of caution than open itself up to a lawsuit. $235/hr is better than a million dollar lawsuit. There is so much misinformation going around the district and it's so sad. It's so easy to blame the current board or new superintendent & her staff for the problems we're facing - the root of these problems are years old. So knock off the smack talk, recognize that changes need to be made, not everyone is going to like them but really what is the alternative? I guess selling your house or sending your kids to private school is always an option - best of luck to you.
Are you kidding me?
8:44 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
No Rose, you are wrong, he is finding violations that the board president has made time after time. Stirring the pot, not exactly. When a board member runs for office and takes an oath, they need to follow it. Thats what they argreed too. Yes alot of misinformation going on and its unacceptable. Even worse, the board making stupid mistakes, and Rains just standing there like a deer in headlights looking at Kenny to see what she should do next. Yes, I am blaming the current board for all this financial mess the district is in because they ignored it till now, and for the 1st time in this districts history harsh changes have been made. Kenny is the president and has been on the board 35 years...where has she been? Has she not paid attention to what has happened financially to this country and state. Now she and the others are making decisions they never thought they would have too. Sorry Rose, I dont feel sorry for them. Other school district have been making cut backs for a few years, but NOT Summit Hill till now, that is their own faults. I will continue to as you put it "smack talk" all I want, because it is the truth. I recognize that changes have to be made and no one will be happy with them, except for the smiling faces at the school board meetings. Too late for alternatives. Selling my house? yes, after the next election.
Rose C
10:08 am on Friday, March 30, 2012
@Are you kidding-none of the 'violations' have been proven to be true. And all that has come from them is attorneys fees.
I have been attending meetings for a while now, I can say that the new board has been looking for ways to cut the budget since KP retired. Just because you may have just started paying attention to what's happening when you jumped on the 'this board sucks wagon', doesn't make what you are saying true.
As far as Mrs. Kenny goes, if you had done your homework you would know that Mrs. Kenny has been fighting to cut the wasteful spending in the budget for years! Do a little research, you can listen to old podcasts on the Summit Hill website, and you will hear her fighting with Mr. Pain & other board members to make cuts last year BEFORE the election. You don't have to like her, & she doesn't need you to feel sorry for her - she has been one of the few people that has consistantly worked hard for what is best (not necessarily what's popular) for ALL of the children of the district.
I recommend that you also review the cost containment package that was put forward by Mr. Pain and HIS board members. It was supposed to cut $2.1 million dollars for the 2010-11 school year. When in fact the cuts were less than $500k. This info is all public record.
Blame whoever you want, complain as much as you want, but unless you have some tangible ideas on how to make things better between now & the next school board election - you're just spewing just hot air.
taxpayer
2:16 pm on Friday, March 30, 2012
@ Rose, touche. What you said is 100% accurate and dead on. Sadly, the community members that are just now paying attention will only remember her most recent actions and frustrations. They have no clue all the good she has done in her 30+ years on the board.
Rose C
7:30 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@Jaimi-Mrs. Klein was asked to work with the administration to continue to develop the best curriculum for the kids. I believe she is paid a stipend and from what I've heard she doing a great job at 1/10 of the cost of a full time Curriculum Dir. @Kerri-I completely agree with you. @Dana - can you please be more specific on who is overpaid & underworked? It seems to me that with staff resigning left & right they leave everyone else with more responsibilities. You also need to understand the law & teachers' contract. It is sad when any teacher loses their job. Especially new ones with fresh ideas. Unfortunately Illinois LAW sets the guidelines on how teachers are let go. There is nothing any board or administrator can do about that. Taxpayer is right, lower enrollment means staff reductions. It sucks but any company has to cut staff when demand goes down.
Rose C
7:53 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
@ Jaimi - one other question do you actually know any of the board members? Have you ever been in a hot seat having to make decisions for 3500 students, 350+ staff members, an annual budget over $40 million and follow the guidelines set forth by the State of Illinois (which hasn't made a 'rational' decision in YEARS) and President Bush's less than perfect No Child Left Behind? Maybe you have, and if that's the case you should have the experience to run next April. I'm thinking you should contact board members directly and really inform yourself as to what goes into sitting in one of those 7 chairs? You know what would be even BETTER? If we could shine at light on you - you sound like the type of person who knows everything about everything and have never made an irrational decision in your life, maybe we could learn something. What is it they say about glass houses?
Zahara
9:33 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
None of this makes sense
Zahara
9:45 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
If people were really informed they would know that a lot of the above posts are not true. Pay attention to what is going on, what you hear, what your kids are saying...the district was fine until the newest board came to be..and how did they get there..peoples vote or non vote. Lesson learned, pay attention to the election . The kids are what everyone has been taught as important...why have the "officials" decided it is more about administrators and teachers vs. student achievment???These kids will suffer if the students needs are not put first, Also, when people are willing to listen to "friends" and not facts...this also leads to problems. The kids in 161 need all the support they can get, not a teacher who is fearing an "honorable dismissal". Support the teachers, support the staff, support the adminstration...this board, needs to have their priorities put into check.
taxpayer
10:23 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Zahara. This district was not OK before this newest Board. The former Superintendent and the Board members who where there under Keith Pain made decisions and past motions while no one was paying attention. No one even attended board meetings up until recently. We can only put partial blame on the Board since they couldn't predict the economy tanking. The community wasn't paying attention because we never heard from the previous Superintendent. Not to mention we didn't have the Patch keeping us updated. I believe people are now aware because Barb Rains opened that line of communication with emails and board updates. The previous Superintendent NEVER EVER informed the community of what was going on. If you actually have hours and hours of time, you can go back and listen to previous podcasts. This district was not OK. Why cuts were not made 2 and 3 years ago, well I think only Keith Pain, Sean Doyle, Joy Murphy, Mary Kenny and Denise Lenz can answer that.
get real
11:05 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
This school district WAS NOT fine before the new school board came to be! The old school board just knew how to hide and lie about it better!!!!
Zahara
5:34 am on Friday, March 30, 2012
It just seems like there is an agenda, and that someone is a puppet on strings. Under previous administration things didn't seem so...personal. If you are living the situation you would understand, but most of the people commenting are outsiders looking in.
taxpayer
7:44 am on Friday, March 30, 2012
I am not sure how many outsiders are looking in but for me personally, I am an insider looking in. I am not sure how much you know about the previous board but there is a reason why Ken Balcerzak and Dave Macek were voted out. They were Keith Pains puppets on strings, along with Sean Doyle and Dee Molinare. Last year they knew cuts needed to be made but instead they cut full time positions for a social worker and nurse, then gave the previous Superintendent a raiseAND contract extention along with a 2.1% raise for all administrators. So was the previous board looking out for our children and their needs or the former Super and administrators. They did what Keith Pain wanted ALWAYS. There is also a reason why Keith Pain suddenly resigned taking his raise with him. This new board was left picking up the pieces of the mess left behind. Serious cuts need to be made and this board is left to do that. What they need to stop doing is their sneak attacks......weather its intentional or not, it needs to stop. They need to work to pull this community together and start repairing our district.
Zahara
8:25 pm on Friday, March 30, 2012
@taxpayer, first of all it is whether, not weather...and secondly what happened previously may also have had personal attacks but now it is even more apparent. The board is acting like politicians who have no idea what is going on...oh, pay based on scores, no child left behind, what is next? This board has gone above and beyond in displaying their likes and dislikes publicly. How is that fair to good, honest people trying to make a difference in youth today? Try doing the job of a teacher, administrator, para-professional etc...and if you do, as you say you are an insider...open your eyes and actually see what is going on.
taxpayer
9:17 pm on Friday, March 30, 2012
Zahara, I have responded respectfully to you. Never oncehave I been disrespectful in my comments. Sorry for speaking what I see at the meetings I have been attending for the past 2 or so years. My eyes are wide opened. I see what is going on and I also see how the community responds when someone comments to their posts that they don't like.
As for the No Child Left Behind..........the Board didn't make up that law, the State did. I haven't heard anything at any board meeting indicating that teachers get paid based on scores. You can go online and see what each and every teacher, and administrator in this district makes.
I hope to see you at the next Board meeting!!!
jd
10:08 pm on Friday, March 30, 2012
informed
9:36 pm on Friday, March 30, 2012
I was just told that The Union Vice President Geobal has been feeding information to Mr. Richard Marron the trouble maker that likes to attack the board and hear himself talk at the school board meetings which is racking up legal fees and nothing comes of his ridulious accusations....neighbors of theirs told me how interesting it is that Geobal and Marron live across the street from one another.....it seems as though the triangle is Geobal, Doyle and the dupe doing their dirty work.
@ informed this all makes sense now. All the information I listened to from Richard Maron seemed to come from a very disgruntled teacher. I listened to what the District lawyer presented, if this is the same information that was presented to the staff at teacher institute, then what is the problem? It clearly wasn't legal advise, it was information regarding a new state law that effects teachers and districts in the state of Illinois. We are learning more and more every time Mr. Maron speaks. The pieces are all falling into place.
Karen O'Malley
10:10 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
I cant believe this board and their friends feel as if they need to attack this teacher and Mr. Maron. Seems to me everything he speaks of during the meetings is public knowledge!! What insider things have been reported? I have been at the last 2 board meetings and what is inside info??? Sad! This sounds as if they need someone to attack to take the focus off themselves. Shows how dirty these people will play!
jd
10:40 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@Karen O'Malley you have only attended the last 2 meetings, just a suggestion for you you might want to sit down and listen to when this all started and how the last board called the deficit a budget imbalance. So as not to alarm the community, elections were coming. Try starting there at the February 2010 podcast and the majority of the board decided that no cuts were needed. Kudos to Murphy, Kenny and Lenz for pushing to make cuts and they were voted down.
Tom Kriznel
10:15 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
Why cant this board just play by the rules and be happy that the public now wants to get more informed and be included. Seems like they are not happy that we disagree with some of their actions. TOO BAD We are tax payers and parents who have a right to our opinions. WE voted for you and it seems you all have personal agendas. Lets see if Ms. Murphys boyfriend gets in and then you tell me that they have no personal agendas. I hear their are many qualified people, but will they consider them? They do illegal meetings and inappropriate quotes in the papers and ask for support. Do what is right for the kids and the community and maybe then we can start to support you.
jd
10:51 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@ Tom Kriznel I didn't realize that the board was charged with doing illegal meetings. That surely would have hit the paper. Let me know where I can find this information. Also, doing nothing like the last board will only cause a larger deficit(oh excuse me imbalance as the last board stated in the 2010 February workshop yes I said workshop) and put a larger burden on this community. I beg of you, listen to the podcasts of meetings you didn't attend, so you can be an informed community member, parent and taxpayer. On a side note what this board is doing is there job, not a pretty one, but one that needed to be done several years ago, and it was ignored and dumped in their lap. Again kudos to all of the board members that are taking their job and large deficit seriously.
informed
10:27 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
What was the problem that a positive informational presentation regarding SB7 was given to the teachers? What was the reason it was brought to the board meeting by a random citizen....who by the way lives across the street from the Union Vice president? Come on, Poor teacher...having this dupe do dirty work.....I am sick that she seems to be connected to the situation.
This school board (volunteers) are doing the right thing by ignoring these comments and trimming down deficit....keep forging ahead!
Karen O'Malley
10:56 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
Informed (JM) sad to see all your personal agendas are coming into place. SCOTT SMALTER is the new assistant principal and Jim Martin is the new principal at Summit Hill. WOW Murphy you got what you wanted!!!!!!!!!
Tom Kriznel
11:00 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
Sad to see that happen! Even sadder that the community knows this info before its even voted in. Scott Smalter has to be voted into the next board meeting, I hope that people attend to witness the dirty politics in Frankfort.
Dede
11:14 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
Dirty politics in this district is not new. Teachers have been victims for years. Politics has been put over what's best for the students for quite some time. Anyone ever wonder why the district office has such a turnover?
Rose C
9:02 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@Karen & Tom, an opening for SHJH Principal would need to be posted first for (I believe) about 2 weeks, interviews would then need to be conducted, and then the selected candidate would go before the board. I don't know Mr. Smalter's qualifications, but he would need a certain level of education to become a vice principal or principal - who he is friends with doesn't matter if he doesn't have the paperwork. Mr. Martin is the assistant superintendent - why would he take a demotion to be a Junior High Principal. Also, SHJH already has an assistant principal. Also Tom, Board members have the same rights under the 1st amendment (freedom of speech) as you do. You don't have to agree with what they are saying, but they have every right to say it. Just like you have every right to blast them here...of course I would be careful because defamation of character and libel are a class 2 misdemeanors punishable both civilly and criminally.
informed
11:02 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@jd - why bother answering @Karen O'Malley and @Tom Kriznel's comments
they seem to be the same as @Are you kidding me? and @citizen anyway....looks like screen names are just being changed.
Are you kidding me?
1:26 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
Informed, yea I change it every day just to start more BS.
Tom Kriznel
11:05 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
No comment about the new info, informed (JM)?
informed
11:09 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@Tom Kriznel - no it's not JM -- I have never changed my screen name unlike you.
jd
11:10 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@ Tom and Karen, WOW great information, but i think your info could be wrong, I heard Laura Gobel is up for the postition. Can't wait to see who is going to be picked, May the best person for our children be picked.
informed
11:18 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@jd, teachers have said that Goebal has tried for many administrive positions throughtout our district I wonder why has she been overlooked?
Citizen
1:25 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@JD Please,We need to stick to facts, not what you heard.
informed
11:15 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@Karen O'Malley - usually rumors come true...please don't lose sleep over this.
I believe Murphy's personal agenda was already taken care of one year ago in May,
now her agenda seems to be to trim the deficit that should have been done last year.
informed
11:33 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
Maybe Mayor Maron knows who the next principal and asst. will be at SHJH?
Last I heard Barb Rains will be principal and Sparty the mascot is going to be asst. principal -- I am comparing that to the other ridiculious comments that have been posted.
Geobal ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!!!
jd
12:09 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@citizen my goal is to get the correct information out, not to discredit anyone, that is your take on things. We need to stick to facts, the information you are putting on here doesn't seem to be fact by your own account. Just trying to sort things out for myself to be an informed parent, community member, taxpayer and voter. And if it is true that these administrators are doing what you say they are doing, how is that helping the situation that is all to clear here. This only hurts our children with their actions.
jd
12:55 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@citizen just to follow up, I would like to know, I must have missed it that Pain was retiring early, Like I said before, I did not hear he retired early on any podcast, unless you are a personal friend of his I would imagine that you would not have that information. So as for the other administratiors, are you a personal friend of each of theirs to say they are retiring early also, or just not fact again.
taxpayer
2:26 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
Not to butt in or anything but at the Board Meeting on May 25, 2011, Mr. Pain officially retired. This would be an early retirment since he had just been given a contract extention and pay raise shortly before May of 2011. PLUS he still had time left on his original contract.
Citizen
1:08 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@JD I'll go back and re-read my comments beacause I didn't realize that i was dis-crediting anyone. Unless you think an Adminstrator retiring is bad thing. I don't know what your trying to say in this statement "And if it is true that these administrators are doing what you say they they are doing, how is that helping the situation that is all to clear here." Please tell.
jd
2:03 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@citizen please go and re-read from March 31 at 11:42am you accused me of trying to dis-credit you. As for retiring personal preference. That statement is solely based on what you have said would happen if these teachers retire early. So now are you saying what you said is untrue? Don't try and confuse the situation.
You seem to have more info on Pain than the rest of the administrators, are you a personal friend or are you Pain? Im sure you won't answer the question. So for me, I am just going to disregard all of your statements, as I have said before just trying to get the facts.
jd
3:08 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@taxpayer I need to do more research on this early retirement thing. I need to go an listen to May 2011poadcast so I can hear what was said,almost seems like these administrators can just get out of their contract when they want. How could he retire early if he was given a pay raise (remember we already were in a budget deficit of 1.6million plus when the old board gave him a raise, i remember the vote being split)
and a new contract and just walk away. Is that what the old board did,gave him a contract that he could leave when he wanted. Thank goodness the majority of that board is gone. Talk about mistakes this new board is making, we as a community are still paying for the mistakes of the old board.
taxpayer
3:31 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
jd, you might want to start with the April 6th, 2011 podcast. This is the meeting where 4 voted yes and 3 voted no on a contract extension and raise for Keith Pain. I was present at these meetings last year. The Board approved a raise even though the community that was in attendance argued against it. Seriously though, you might want to go back to maybe March of 2011 and work your way to the May 25th retirement. This will give you a better idea of the bogus things that were going on then. As for why Pain took the raise and ran......well, I have my own thoughts and ideas on that. Since its only speculation on my part, I will not post since I don't have hard facts. Lets just say in my opinion, we are far better off with Keith Pain gone.
Good luck listening to the podcasts!!!
Citizen
4:13 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
a few things.....yes the board approved a raise for Pain and all Administrators. But he didn't take the money and run- he quit. 161 was under no obligation to pay him after June 30th (his last day). When Mr. Pain told TRS (Teachers Retirement System) of his intention to retire early, District 161 had to make a one-time deposit of around 200k toward his pension. Mr Pain also had make one-time TRS payment on his own (although considerably smaller). As for why he suddenly left, in my opinion he saw the board was 5-2 against him. They would have made it almost impossible for him to do his job, leaving was what was best for him and the district.
Rose C
9:22 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
@ Citizen - I think you are partially correct about Mr. Pain. He did retire early, causing the district to make a lump sum payment to TRS...however I do question why he 'suddenly' left. We all have had to work with difficult people, Mr. Pain did not even try to work with his new board. I'm pretty sure they were in office for one meeting and then next meeting he announced his retirement. I don't know what his motivations were, maybe he didn't want to have to justify his actions with people who would question his agenda. Maybe it was because he was ripped to shreds in public comments by a parent at the 1st meeting in May - there is no podcast available for that meeting. What does that say about him? I get that it is easier to do your job when you are working with your buddies who would never question your agenda, and in this case - his feet were about to be held to the fire. Or maybe he realized the financial mess was about to be exposed and he headed for the hills. If that's why, I don't blame him. I guess he is the only one who can answer that. Although I have to tell you, the people I know in the community, including teachers, staff & parents - were thrilled to see him go. I did a little dance myself.
taxpayer
9:18 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
I was at the May Board Meeting and, the letter from KP that was read indicated he "retired", not "quit". In what podcast or meeting did the Board indicate that the TRS made a one time deposit of 200K to his pension?? I'd like to hear the truth on this. The beautiful thing about the freedom of speech is that we also have the freedom of opinion. I respect your opinion Citizen on the KP thing. I feel that if what you say is true, then he bailed when the going got tough. In my opinion, I feel he bailed because he knew some of his actions were wrong and didn't want them exposed. On top of that, 2 of his coronies were dismissed of their board duties. A person doesn't accept a contract extension and pay raise, and then all of a sudden quits. Again, I am just one opinion, and I respect you Citizen for you opinion.
James Landon
2:25 pm on Sunday, April 1, 2012
I live in Arbury Hills and unfortunately I have heard the same thing. How is it that the board has not even from what I understand posted the positions for assistant principal at Walker, or the principal job at Summit Hill and they are filled???? If these are just rumors then so be it...time will tell but if this Mr. Smalter gets the principal job then we know what kind of people we are dealing with. BOARD BE FAIR TO ALL not just your friends or boyfriends.
Are you kidding me?
4:58 pm on Sunday, April 1, 2012
So with all these changes and the last one Smalter @HW, and Martin at the JH. Gerdes and Egan are leaving too! That means Rains all by herself, now she will probley hire Duster back!
Dede
10:51 am on Tuesday, April 24, 2012
Legally, I thought positions HAD to be posted, although in this district, the decision is sometimes made before the posting.
hmm
3:09 pm on Wednesday, April 25, 2012
Duster is a super himself now a days
jd
5:27 pm on Sunday, April 1, 2012
Rumors, Rumors, Rumors, maybe we should all wait and see what happens. The only thing we should all PRAY for is that our childrens educational needs are taken care of and that the best people will all be picked for our district. I am going to PRAY really hard that happens.
Rose C
9:25 pm on Sunday, April 1, 2012
I have to say that I am very disappointed with how this message board floats out information as if ANY of it is proven to be fact. Rumors & scandal make for great TV but it is very destructive to our community. I am a firm believer in a person's right to their opinion, even if I disagree with them. However, things that are being posted here are just mean, false & sometimes plain ignorant. I hope that people who take the time to read the Patch (especially the ones who keep their comments/opinions to themselves) realize that the majority of the things written in the above 82 comments are false. I would hope that they would take the time to investigate for themselves the truth. Rumor & speculation is just that. The other downside to all of this 'banter' is the fact that our district has a couple of very important openings that need to be filled as soon as possible - Director of Finance & Special Ed Director. I don't know about any of you, but when I have looked for a job in the past, I do my research to find out if I would want to work for that company. I fear that this mayhem would discourage great applicants from coming to work in our district. That is really sad. We need to have a good team in place to keep our district moving forward & advancing what is best for all of the kids in the district. Maybe you can think about that before you type any more lies behind your fake screen names.
taxpayer
8:04 am on Monday, April 2, 2012
THANK YOU Rose!!! You are again spot on with your post. The way some of my fellow neighbors are gossiping, and fueling the fire, is like listening to a bunch of grammer school kids. We are suppose to be acting like adults and setting an example for our children.
Tracy
7:14 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
Anyone else's kid come home from school yesterday saying a teacher told children that Klein is going to Rogus, and Ruffalo is going to HW? Mine did. Not naming the teacher, but my kid is at MD, and why is she and her friends hearing things before the board votes or decides or Rains sends out a communication? Rumor or not, those were the words my child said a teacher said, this isn't the way the teachers should be handling themselves either.
Are you kidding me?
8:00 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
Tracy, Yes...Rains sent an email Friday: Kathy Klein and Christine Carey as Co-Principals who will be sharing the leadership of Rogus. Frankfort Square will be Isdonas as Principal. Walker getting Ruffalo as Principal. And we also heard Martin is stepping down to be the Principal at the Junior High and Smalter going to HW to be Assist. Principal.
Your right about the teachers, but I think is was Rains responsibility to handle this better. I hear the moral at all the schools is the worst, and what happened to the Principal at the Junior High is disrespectful and shows the students there that PBIS does not apply to adults.
sam
8:11 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
So if Scott Smalter is taking over as assistant principal at SHJH as everyone "assumes" what happens to the current assistant principal Christine Hudziak?
Rose C
10:13 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
@Are you kidding - who are you to say things should be handled differently? You are obviously lacking facts throughout your posts, I have a feeling this is just another instance where you didn't check YOUR facts. As for morale in the buildings - I'd check your sources. I have heard the opposite. And I have heard that the Mary Drew families moving to DJR are thrilled Klein will be moving with them. I'm guessing you are in that 10% that they say will never be happy no matter what happens.
Tracy
11:48 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
I have a student at MD and one at SHJH, the morale, according to them, is down amongst the kids. It has to do with how THEIR world is being affected, how will they go to clubs without activity buses if their parents work. How could their favorite teacher go? Why is a principal going to be a teacher now? My teacher is not tenured, but she's the best, why are they firing her mom? That's a few examples of what my kids and their friends have been asking.
The kids are worried about what is happening, each have questions daily for me, that I can't answer. They are coming home with more information than parents are receiving. There are other children from MD that aren't going to Rogus. There are MD and FS 4th graders and parents who arn't thrilled to see Ruffalo going to HW. And, there are some who are thrilled. There is no right or wrong in feelings.
Rose, please keep in mind, your opinions and observations are not all facts either. People are just voicing their thoughts and concerns. Please, when a parent states their child isn't happy, respect that as much as you do hearing a parent say their child is. I like hearing what you have to share, but we don't fit in a % when it comes to feelings. My kids have a right to question things and feel disappointment in what's happening. I have a right to ask why are children are hearing things through teachers. It bothers me that a teacher at each school has told each of my children that they lost their job, not very professional.
taxpayer
12:18 pm on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
@ Tracy, I'm sorry to hear your kids are being affected by adult decisions. A teacher should not be discussing anything that is not educational to the children. I can understand your MD child being affected but your JH child?? If his/her teachers are discussing these matters to the students at SH, I would suggest maybe an email to the teacher. Honestly, I have a daughter at SH and she has no idea about teacher and administration moving around. I havent discussed this in front of my children nor has she said anything about teachers discussing this.
Tracy
12:48 pm on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
Tax - I know, to hear the kids in JH are bothered, but the word of Lind and Mr. Cardinal has gotten around. Cardinal is his favorite teacher. And that was going across the school before the last board meeting. He's worried about clubs, not the cost, but will he personally get to be in them if no buses or participation goes down, will they cancel them all together. I just keep saying no worries until next year.
My kids are getting annoyed with me now because I wont discuss much with them, cause the truth is, I don't know enough to have the discussions with them. And it does affect all the schools really, SHJH teachers make up 8 or 9 of the teachers being let go, and the kids seem to know Encore program is changing. So, makes sense it would affect the 7th graders thinking about what will happen in 8th grade. We keep forgetting it's not just MD closing, but changes throughout the whole district are happening.
informed
9:57 pm on Wednesday, April 4, 2012
@are you kidding me? This has to be Sean William with all the facts.
taxpayer
9:13 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
Was this an email sent to district residence or just the employees of 161?? I haven't received any email indicating who is going where.
If this was an email sent to the employees of 161, then Rains did her job by informing the staff before the public. I will have to put fault on the teachers for "gossiping" while in and outside of school. These children shouldn't be involved and the teachers should not be discussing this with their class. That is our job as parents.
Tracy
9:24 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
Thanks Are - no, saw no email here.
I guess I don't understand, how does one become prinicpal or asst principal? There isn't a hiring process? Pople can step down or raise their hand and say, oh, I'll do that... How does anyone 'outside' ever get in this district?
And yes, MD kids around me, who had once gone to Rogus, were not to happy to hear that they would be under Ruffalo again.
And yes Sam - what happens to Hudziak?
Who exactly is mapping all of this out anymore anyway? Rains? The Board? I seriously don't get how this is working now.
Why all the shifting to begin with? Did we need to lose Lind? Do we know the grounds for that reclassification yet? Klein could have easily just slipped over to HW - a school w/out a prinicipal, a principal without a school - seems simple enough. This gets stranger every day.
Tracy
9:29 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
And wait a min... Martin's salary... he's stepping down, so I am assuming that is less pay. He is accepting less pay? Or no, and we'll be hiring a new asst sup, at the higher pay scale.
Has a list been issued of the teachers going? I thought Joe was going to have that, and I assumed it would be posted in the Patch, or was that in an email I didn't get too?
ANd yes, I have been following here, just didn't want to ask earlier when all the craziness was going on in the comments above, but I sincerely do have questions I'd like to know about - this principal situation. I still want to see the money bottom line being saved on MD closing and 22 teachers going (and is it me, wasn't that stated in the model of the closing of MD, that it would be only 9 teachers... help me out here)
Serioulsy?
9:47 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
I heard that Santa Claus is going to give up his job at the North Pole to be principal at the Jr. High and the Tooth Fairy is going to be the assistant principal at HW. My kids are soooooooo excited!
Tracy
9:52 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
Is it sad that all of a sudden I thought wait a minute, there's a leprechaun out there that has to be friends with one of the board members though...
Ok, obviously then, I can't be the only one wondering how this process is working. I really should say now, maybe I should be principal. Nice hours, close to home, oh wait, I mean asst sup... that will be the next fill in position available it sounds like.
How long has Martin been asst sup?
Rose C
10:10 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
Stop! Get some facts before you post! Mr. Martin isn't going anywhere - why on earth would he agree to step down? Mr. Smalter is a teacher at SHJH - that's it! Mrs. Hudziak is still the vice principal at SHJH. Ruffalo is going to HW. Isdonas is going to Square & Carey & Klein are headed to DJR. The board votes on retaining/hiring employees - it is not their job to decide where to place them. That is the role of the superintendent. Because it is a personnel matter Mrs. Rains may have discussed it in closed session but that is pure speculation unless you are a member of the board.
@ Tracy - as far as moving Mrs. Klein to HW, she may not be certified to be a middle school principal or and I'm just speculating, or she could have said 'thanks but no thanks', you should call & ask her. In regards to the teachers that were let go, Joe did say he would only receive the list of teachers that are staying. There are privacy rules to follow. Which is also why the reclassification is under wraps too. As for the 22 vs 9, we were told in a couple of board meetings & the workshop, positions would be streamlined. I hate to see teachers let go, but we knew sacrifices would be made at every building.
sam
10:17 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
I have a question maybe someone could answer a little off the above subject. How did Mary Drew School qualify as an award winning school? What award did it win? I know that when Mary Drew was principal at Hilda Walker School, she won the Blue Ribbon Award for Hilda Walker School. I believe that was in 2001. Just curious.
Tracy
11:10 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
The Summit Hill page explains the history of awards. It's consistency over years of meeting or exceeding Illinois Learning Standards.
http://www.summithill.org/
Serioulsy?
10:25 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
There is an email going out on Wednesday about all the principal changes if you guys can wait. At least then you will know what is rumor and what is fact. Until then, why don't we all just take a deep breath and relax. Doesn't matter who is going where as long as our kids continue to receive an outstanding education. @Rose C. -- thank you for being the voice of reason on this comment board.
Tracy
11:21 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
I will gladly wait for the email. Glad to hear something is coming.
I disagree that it doesn't matter though. Not in the sense of the children, the kids need / will receive outstanding education. It will be an issue in the lack of ethics feel happening, cause there is one out there. Some things just wont 'look' good if some of these rumors are in fact true, don't you think? But until we see what happens, who knows. I just think some things, if they happen, (and no, I'm not spelling it out, enough people have) will not look good, but only add to the sneaky feel the board has left open in our community. I fear all he## could let loose possibly, and hope not, this community really needs to work together. There are some things that appear to be a conflict of interest to some, so let's hope the communication to explain the decisions is in the email.
Tracy
11:02 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012
See, this is why I didn't ask questions earlier, everyone, please calm down. I asked why my kid is hearing things from teachers, that is a concern for all here. All, stop claiming what is a fact or not, cause who knows until it happens. Maybe a lot of things here are being questioned, but it sounds like many are yelling through their tone of writing. Unless anyone here is Rains or the Board, it's all hearsay isn't it? Fact is, very few here know the facts, they are just trying to piece together what looks like what might be happening.
The night of the Wendy's MD fund raising, I did ask Klein 'I have to ask, cause I don't want to be an advocate to something you don't want, but it seems to make sense, are you going to go to HW if you can?' She replied 'I don't know if I will be going there or anywhere, I just know MD is closed, but I told Mrs. Rains I would go to HW, and that I am not ready to retire, really any of the schools, except SHJH.' Glad she wants to stay with D161. Now if she had a choice or was simply told you're going to Rogus, I don't know. What I do know is that my child, and the neighborhood children were upset that Mrs. Meyers is not tenured, so she's gone, and that Ruffalo is going to HW. Which made me ask them 'How do you know this?' And they replied a teacher told them, so I said 'Well, don't believe everything you're hearing right now, and not to worry about any of that, just go play.' Maybe the only people we can trust in right now is the children.
caspert
7:34 am on Wednesday, April 4, 2012
@ concerned parent how do you know an email is coming on wednsday? As far as an outstanding education that changed when a school closed, clubs gone, and staff and good teachers honorably fired. Please tell me how adding more kids in a classroom is outstanding? Anything that used to set us apart from other districts is gone or will be gone next year. You are fooling yourself if you really believe it will be just as good. Really? Makes teachers jobs harder and more stressful. The reason it was so good was because of all those things that are now gone. All those suggestions given without properly being researched and this is the easy way out. It's amazing what other districts have cut but We couldn't get some of those things done I don't understand it. You have a handful of board members saying that everything was rushed and some wrong desicions are being made without proper research and info. Maybe outstanding has a new definition?
taxpayer
9:45 am on Wednesday, April 4, 2012
caspert, I respect your opinion and If what you are saying is true that it will be stressful to have a few more kids in a class then the teachers at Rogus Kindergarten, Rogus 1-4, Indian Trail, and Mary Drew are WAY STRESSED. Classes at those schools have been over 20 kids. There was a 3rd grade class at IT last year that was at the max. I believe by adding kids to classrooms at FS and Arbury will not add stress OR to anyother school that has a handful of kids in a class. We all would love to have 15-19 kids per class but the reality is, you only get that at a private institution. I for one want to see classes evened out across the board. Schools that have low class sizes will do fine with a few more kids added to the class. The bigger schools in our district have managed, and I don't see my childs education lacking because he has 24 kids in his class.
Rose C
12:37 pm on Wednesday, April 4, 2012
I have to ask Caspert, how do you know that 'all those suggestions were given without being properly researched?' Are you getting information from another source that the rest of us aren't priivy to? If so, please share. What is it YOU would have like to have seen cut? You're obviously upset about 1-4 clubs, really? I think so long as the class size guidelines aren't increased, why would we see overcrowded classrooms? I have heard at several board meetings that raising class sizes is not something the board or community wants to see happen. Hypothetically speaking -How would you operate this is district if you were running the show? Would you have kept all buildings open, all staff, extracurriculars, activity buses, & everything else that was cut? If so, how would you pay for all of that? Just because some parents want their taxes increased, fees raised, a $150 per student "donation", pay to ride the buses - I don't & I'd be willing to bet that alot of your friends & neighbors wouldn't want that either. Aren't you glad that you don't have to make the tough decisions? I'm glad those heartless, evil, self-centered (volunteer) board members - who are out to get us & ruin the education our children deserve - have to make these decisions. It's so much more fun to sit back & complain about how stupid they are. I bet that Borgens woman wishes she had kept her trap shut & stayed in the audience to write her ridiculous e-mails. This Monday morning quarterback thing is fun! (sarcasm)
Serioulsy?
8:08 am on Wednesday, April 4, 2012
@Caspert -- I know that an email is coming because I picked up the phone and asked. Amazing what you can find out by just picking up the phone. As for an outstanding education, I was referring to the actual education my kids have been receiving, not the clubs as I consider those extracurricular activities. My daughter is a straight-A student and had 25-26 kids in her classroom for both 3rd and 4th grade and her education didn't suffer. The classroom size guidelines aren't changing, it is still 27 kids for 3rd and 4th and 25 for 1st and 2nd. Yes, I am upset that good teachers were honorably fired, it sucks for them. However, the district is in trouble and the board had to do something, so I trust that they made the right decision. Only time will tell.
caspert
9:24 am on Wednesday, April 4, 2012
You must have a different phone line or connection? Who exactly did you call and talk to? I knew when I wrote the comment above the clubs was going to be picked out because no one really wants to address the rest of it because its true. As far as the max many classrooms weren't at the max so it is adding kids to a classroom and changing things. Honorably fired? There is nothing honorable about getting fired you can add any fancy word to it and it sucks for everyone not just the teachers. If the right descions were made then why wasn't it unanimous? Did anyone talk to the teachers and ask them what they thought? Did all board members visit all the schools and see how they run or just the ones they reside in? Teachers and staff are the ones on the front lines doing the actual work. Again things they set our district apart and put us above the rest are gone now. Why the catch phrase a 3 year plan? All smoke and mirrors. An informed researched plan with consulting individuals with a background in finances would of been a better option. Yes the district is in trouble all right. I agree with you on only time will tell. But it is at the expense of our kids.
Rose C
12:16 pm on Wednesday, April 4, 2012
Caspert would you really want our school board to come out & agree unanimously on every decision- especially on closing a building or ending FDK? I would suspect something REALLY shady was going on if they sat down agreed to everything without a discussion & the meeting was over in 30 minutes or less. I'm happy that these 7 people (regardless of how I may feel about them personally) actually discuss the process in front of an audience. I can understand your frustration with great teachers losing their jobs, however the State has tied the hands of school districts - google Senate Bill 7, it will turn your stomach. They have changed the rules on how teachers can be let go & re-hired in the event that the need arises. I have children at 3 different buildings & guess what I have seen several (not all) board members at assemblies & other school events at each of my children's schools. Not sure if you are aware of this but the last board removed the 'language' from board policy that board members are required to go into buildings. I remember this distinctly because it blew my mind. Why would you want to be on a school board if you have no interest in going into the buildings?
I think you need to research before you rant-for the 7 years that I was in this district before KP retired, there was little to no community or teacher involvement in decision making. It sounds to me like you want the smoke & mirrors back rather than face the reality of the mess that was left behind.
Serioulsy?
10:16 am on Wednesday, April 4, 2012
@caspert - I talked to the principal at my daughter's school and he told me that they were supposed to be sending out an email at 3:45 today. I don't think bit is a secret. As for using term "honorably fired" you used it first, I was merely following suit. I agree with you that things are going to change and I'm conecerned (obviously) but I'm trying to have a positive outlook. @Taxpayer - my son went to frankfort square last year and had 26 kids in his classroom. Same for his 3rd grade class. Right now they have 22 in 3rf and 4th. Qst and 2nd do, however, only have 18.
taxpayer
12:51 pm on Wednesday, April 4, 2012
@ Rose, well said.
I have been in this district since 1999. I was here before there were all of these wonderful programs that we have today. My oldest did just fine. Our district was fortunate to have been able to add and enhance the education of our children when the economy was great. Unfortunately, some of those perks need to be let go. Not too often was the community notified of any changes, hiring or firings, programs added or elimated, etc. We were only informed if there was a strange car driving around the neighborhood. Because Barb Raines has opened that line of communication, people are more aware of what is going on. Unfortunately, she is feeling the heat because of it. Reality hurts sometimes but the Board and Superintendent need to make cuts that not everyone will be happy with. I have no doubt the children and the teachers will be just fine. As for the Board members visiting the schools. I can honestly say that I have seen them at my childrens schools on numerous occasions.
caspert
9:12 pm on Wednesday, April 4, 2012
Well you 2 really told me. You are right about being in reality. I'm in reality it seems everyone else is busy watching rainbows and unicorns. I number 1 have every right to question things don't fault me. You are acting like others never demanded answers or questioned under K.P. Give me a break! That is not my fault or do I care. btw I'm sick to death of hearing about him its like listening to the presidential races. Guess what we are here now and the actions and the way these decisions have been made are how I'm judging others. Also the way the community is being slammed both at the board meeting and in the papers by a select few of its members. I 'm not ranting at all I'm questioning things. Sorry because you don't agree or its not your opinion that you have a problem with it. My taxes which by the way are not going down but the quality and all the things associated with district 161 is. Maybe others don't work as hard as my family does or just don't care about property values. Well the reason the country, state and school district are in these messes is because no one demands answers, accountability and questions. Maybe if more people did we wouldn't find ourselves in this situation. Lines of communication should always be open we shouldn't be bowing at anyones feet because they finally decided to do it that is the way districts should handle themselves.
taxpayer
9:52 pm on Wednesday, April 4, 2012
I believe you must have just read what you wanted to.... I indicated in my post above, "caspert, I respect your opinion". First of all, people have demanded questions from KP, but ask those people (including me) if we got an honest answer. I also believe if there are valid questions, then by all means, question the Board. The quality of our childrens education is not going down. The curriculum isn't changing, the teachers in our district will continue to teach and educate our children to the best of their ability like they always have. Its the teachers teaching our kids, not the Board. I don't understand how people can say they understand the district needs to make cuts but then complain about the cuts that are made. I sure hope to see you "caspert" and anyone else that feel they can do better, on the ballot to run for one of the volunteer spots on the Board next year.
informed
9:19 pm on Wednesday, April 4, 2012
@Casper the friendly ghost- explain what you meant when you said "My taxes which by the way are not going down but the quality and all the things associated with district 161 is". I don't understand, Summit Hill School is STILL a great school district...
sorry you and a couple people in this community feel this way.
hmm
9:04 am on Wednesday, April 18, 2012
Everyone needs to become well aware of the States inability to pay their bills to our schools, they also need to be aware that the State is most likely pushing the teacher pension programs to the local districts, also the State is most likely pushing to make changes to transportation funding to districts.... YES THE REALITY IS QUALITY OF EDUCATION IN MANY IF NOT ALL WILL START TO DIMINISH. This is reality! You can only do so much financial reform within any organization. Unfortunately it is inevitable that the quality of education will degrade.
Ready for Change
4:24 pm on Thursday, April 26, 2012
Maybe it is finally time for people to realize that the way we fund education, based on property taxes is a big problem. Why not tell legislators to switch funding of education to sales tax and then people who own homes wouldn't be overly burdened. Just a thought....