Which Area Turkey Sandwich Melts Your Heart?

Our taster tried warm turkey sandwiches at three Lincoln-Way restaurants.

See next week's food challenge at the bottom of this column, comment below and you could receive a $50 gift card to a local restaurant in a random drawing. For more rules and details, see the  guidelines.

This week is all about going out to lunch for a Diet Coke, a sandwich and maybe some fries. A staple of lunch is the turkey sandwich, and because a lot of restaurants have a turkey and cheese on their menu, I thought I'd see who makes the best one. The rule: When ordering, I ask for no special instructions or alterations to the sandwich.

, New Lenox

The turkey melt at Williamson's comes on a croissant with thickly sliced turkey that smells and tastes like roasted and carved turkey, not the stuff from a package. The big, flaky croissant was toasted, which dried it out. And what the menu promised would be melted cheddar cheese was actually a cheese sauce, not unlike what is served with pretzel bites at the movie theater. To add insult to injury, the fries were cold. Williamson's is usually quite good, but this lunch really let me down.

The good: Top notch, flavorful turkey breast.

The bad: Quality ingredients were ruined by poor execution and a cheese sauce that would only taste good on pretzels or tortilla chips. 

, Mokena

Because Denny's almost won the , I thought I should get over my snobbery in thinking of Denny's as the place to go only when nothing else is open. I ordered the Super Bird with mashed potatoes as my side. The Super Bird, for those not in the know, has turkey, Swiss cheese, bacon and tomato on sourdough bread.  And it was good! The bacon didn't overpower the sandwich (I'm not a huge bacon fan. I know; I'm odd) and the sourdough was perfectly grilled-- not too brown, not too light. The mashed potatoes were served with a generous amount of cheddar cheese (most of which I scraped off) and were also quite tasty.

The good: A hot turkey sandwich that hit the spot.

The bad: Some of the tomato was a bit underripe.

, Frankfort

The turkey melt at Pete Mitchell's is a very modified Rachel; it has Monterey Jack cheese, tomato and Thousand Island dressing on sourdough and is served with seasoned waffle fries or homemade potato chips. I went with the waffle fries. The waffle fries were a delight and all of the components of the sandwich were great, especially the Jack cheese. However, the warmed up Thousand Island became thin and runny, making the sandwich soggy.

The good: Tasty sourdough bread, turkey, tomato and Jack cheese made a nice, satisfying sandwich.

The bad: The abundance of Thousand Island dressing was unappealing. Next time, I will order it without dressing and it will be a terrific lunch, especially with those crave-worthy seasoned waffle fries. 

THE WINNER: Denny's. The sandwich was warm and yummy. Turns out, it is safe to order non-breakfast items at Denny's. Who knew?

Looking for local eats? Do you disagree with our taster? Head  over to your local Patch Places food and dining directory. Find new spots, read reviews and even post a your own reviews on the profile pages.

Next week's challenge is chocolate cake. Who has the best chocolate cake in Lincoln-Way?

Dee Miller June 24, 2011 at 05:34 AM
The Bird at Denny's has been a favorite of many for over 20 years, they have got that one down right. Too bad Denny's won for the turkey sandwich because their chocolate cake is decadent. It is a triple layer chocolate cake with Hershey's chocolate chips on it, and it is great for the chocolate crave. Rich enough to share with another, or save the rest for later. The carrot cake was almost a winner. Denny's does have good food. we used to go there a lot when the kids were younger, on Tuesday's and Saturday's I believe, kids eat Free, and the kids were happy and so were we.
Michael Sewall June 26, 2011 at 07:38 PM
Hi Dee, you won our random drawing today to be a finalist in our gift card giveaway contest. Next month, we'll have another random drawing among the four finalists to determine the winner. Thank you for reading! To everyone else who commented, make sure to check today's new Chowdown Showdown on chocolate cake, and you'll have a chance to win.
Michael Sewall July 17, 2011 at 05:11 PM
Hey Dee, I just did our monthly drawing and you won the $50 gift card! Thank you for reading. I'll send you an email with more info.
Michael Sewall July 17, 2011 at 05:19 PM
Actually, I just tried emailing you with the email you used to sign into Patch, and I received a bounce back email. If you could please contact me at michael.sewall@patch.com with a working email, I can send you details. If I don't hear from you by Friday at noon, we will conduct another random drawing with the remaining three finalists. Thank you!
Dee Miller July 17, 2011 at 05:55 PM
Wow, thanks so much Michael!!! I will go in my email and clear some out I think it is just full. That is great never expected it!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »