D161 Parents, Board Split Over Dropping Full-Day Kindergarten

As part of trimming the budget over the next three years, the Summit Hill school board wants to eliminate full-day kindergarten. But some argue such a cut will hurt the students.

For the parents and board members of , two hours have become one of the most important things when it comes to the budget cuts facing the district.

Two hours is the time difference between full- and half-day kindergarten programs in the district. , a move that has divided district parents and even members of the board.

Supporters of full-day kindergarten, including board members George Perros, Denise Lenz and Stacey Borgens, argue that dropping the program will have an adverse effect on the education of students.


Even the board members and parents who support getting rid of full-day kindergarten agree that it's a good program and hate to see it go, but that it's a better alternative than closing schools or increasing class sizes. Summit Hill also is one of the few districts in the area--along with and Kirby School District 140 in Orland Park--to have full-day kindergarten.

Some board members reinforced the idea that the district has a strong half-day program that parents can currently enroll their children in. Board Vice President Joy Murphy said half-day kindergarten can be just as effective when it comes to educating students as the full-day program. In fact, during a special budget workshop Saturday, some parents who taught at the elementary level in other districts cited studies showing that the gains a child can have going to a full-day program even out by the time they reach third grade.

But there's a larger underlying issue for some board members who contend that reductions elsewhere should be looked at before the kindergarten program is even put on the table.


"We should cut somewhere where it doesn't have that direct effect (on students)," Perros said in an interview Tuesday. "We're trying to do what's right for the children. We could've found other places to cut."

Borgens agrees, saying she thinks there are other areas that could be trimmed without directly affecting the educational process. She said she passed along suggestions for about $320,000 of possible savings, mostly in administrative cuts, to Supt. Barb Rains to look at to see if they were viable.

"To me, it's not just about full-day kindergarten," Borgens said. "I want to make sure we can make every other cut before we cut it. (Parents) want to see cuts at the top. They want us to make as a many cuts before we take away the full-day program. ... If we exhaust everything we can, then we can go to parents and make the case."

As an alternative, Lenz suggested a tuition-based, full-day kindergarten that would allow parents to foot the bill for the program. Rains and her staff were going to break down the cost and savings of such a program, and the item would be on the agenda of the Wednesday's meeting. Perros said he heard the cost of tuition would be around $2,500, but no official figure has been determined.

SIGN UP: You Won't Miss Any D161 News When You Get Patch's Daily Newsletter

Even though it keeps a full-day program, Borgens and Perros don't support a tuition-based initiative, saying it would discriminate against parents who couldn't afford it.

Some residents have started a petition asking the board to wait to make a final decision on the full-day kindergarten program, said parent Connie Blondin, who is helping to organize the effort. The petition asks to table a decision until the board's Feb. 22 meeting, so that more research can be done on the effects of dropping the program and details are set on what a tuition-based program would look like. Also, it asks for enough time for all D161 parents to be notified if the full-day program is eliminated.

M.D. February 10, 2012 at 03:26 PM
Rose C February 10, 2012 at 04:36 PM
MD - they offered an 'incentive' to parents to register early. After May 31, it's back to $150. Last year the board discussed offering this. It's not news. Had they changed their minds, someone would be slamming them for that. Ask Dr. Wylie how pissed 210 parents are about all the increases to fees he instituted for next year.
Citizen February 10, 2012 at 04:42 PM
Rose, I was wrong on the 5 million dollar reserve figure (it seemed a little low to me), and I apologize to everyone.. As for Perros, Lenz & Borgens wanting to look elsewhere for cuts- what have they been doing for the last 10 weeks? Borgens sent a list of up to 320K in cuts to Rains-were these cuts discussed by the board? I read today that Perros wants to renegotiate the Johnson Control contract (540K). Wasn't Johnson Controls selected from an open bidding process? I totally agree with you on the charging for bus service, but lowering the registration fee when the district can't make ends meet is sending the wrong message.. You say we need solutions, not criticism. Eliminating FDK could (and should in my opinion) be a big part of the solution. And while eliminating FDK may not be off the board, with registration now underway, it's unlikely we will see a change for the 2012-13 school year.
taxpayer February 10, 2012 at 04:43 PM
I agree with Rose. I was at the board meeting when this was discussed. Parents were upset with the late fee. Some people just can't afford it. Because registration had already begun last year, they couldn't elimate the late fee midway through registration. They need numbers and people to register as early as possible. So they agreed to swipe the late fee and give an insentive to people to register early. PLUS, no one could actually tell us what the "late fee" money was used for and how much they actually collected. This insentive was voted on and passed last year.
Hugetxbill February 24, 2012 at 04:47 PM
I have done a lot of research on the Mary Drew project and it is very difficult to find information on this. However, I am mistaken with that number $39 million I believe is a total number for the renovations for summit hill, hilda walker and mary drew. The round about number according to an archived newspaper is around $9 million-still a lot of money considering they want to close it now.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »